Assessing Primary Button Visibility and User Preference

Timeline: 1 week
My Role: UX Researcher
Team: UX Research Lead, Senior UX Designer, Global Communications Team
Method: A/B Testing, Unmoderated
Tools: Figma, Sprig, Confluence

Context

The Global Communications team was rolling out a new color scheme across the myOMERS digital portal. The UX Design team raised concerns that changing the primary button color from orange to blue might make key actions harder for users to notice. Because these buttons drive important interactions, like account management and transactions, it’s crucial that they stand out visually, both to support a smooth user experience and to maintain accessibility for all users.

Study Overview

To quickly inform design decisions, we conducted an unmoderated study which allowed for a faster turnaround compared to moderated sessions. A link to the survey was sent to active and retired members via email.

Participants were shown mockups of the primary button in both orange and blue and asked to provide feedback on:

  • Which of the two colors is preferred by users
  • Which button stands out more at first glance

The study leveraged the Sprig platform to deploy the survey and collect user feedback. Participants provided feedback using a combination of multiple-choice questions to indicate which button they noticed first and which they preferred, as well as open-text responses to explain their reasoning and perceptions.

Key Findings

The study revealed clear patterns:

  1. 73% of participants reported that the orange button was more noticeable and drew attention more quickly than blue.
  2. 61% preferred orange due to its distinctiveness, and 39% who liked the blue button still agreed that orange stood out more visually.
  3. Participants consistently associated orange with high visibility and urgency, indicating it would be more likely to prompt desired actions.

Recommendations

Based on the research:

  1. Keep the orange primary button to maximize visibility and user engagement.

Outcome

The findings were compiled into a concise UX report and shared asynchronously with stakeholders. The report summarized key insights, data visualizations, and participant quotes to clearly communicate the rationale behind the recommendation.

As a result, the team decided to keep the orange primary button, ensuring that key actions remain visually prominent and accessible.

Timeline: 1 weeks
My Role: UX Researcher
Team: UX Research Lead, Senior UX Designer, Global Communications Team
Method: A/B Testing, Unmoderated
Tools: Figma, Sprig, Confluence

Other Projects

Understanding Members’ Retirement Planning Needs
Redesigning the myOMERS Retirement Planner
Designing a Pension Administration Dashboard

Other Projects

Understanding Members’ Retirement Planning Needs
Redesigning myOMERS Retirement Planner
Designing a Pension Administration Dashboard